Claudine gay plagiarism

The validity of evidence becomes wholly subordinate to the question of whether it advances or embarrasses a particular political objective. (AP. Experts say improved technology could bring to light more alleged transgressions in past works by other academic leaders.

The Latest Plagiarism Accusations

Inthe university suspended 27 students and placed another 56 on academic probation for honor code violations, with plagiarism cases comprising the second most common offense after cheating on exams. When researcher Clayton Cramer uncovered evidence that Bellesiles falsified his sources and made unsupported claims from nonexistent historical plagiarisms, academia circled the wagons.

Last year, I discovered signs of possible plagiarism by Kevin M. Kruse, a Princeton historian and left-wing Twitter celebrity. Claudine Gay is simply the latest beneficiary of a leftwing intellectual privilege that not only excuses away research misconduct—it also attempts claudine shift the blame onto the parties who made the discovery, no matter the validity of the evidence.

After dividing the world into oppressors and the oppressed, all other judgment calls depend solely on whether they serve a favored ideological perspective. Introduction Perhaps more than any other issue, claims of skyrocketing economic inequality provided October 4,was the date of the Great Barrington Declaration, a statement by medical professionals that Stay Connected.

For this reason, it is not uncommon to see strident defenses of Gay by the very same academics who howled at Neil Gorsuch and Melania Trump over significantly lesser allegations of plagiarism. Numerous supporters of Gay in the ranks of journalism and academia have dismissed all evidence of her transgressions by attacking the journalists who brought them to light.

In the end, allegations of serial plagiarism proved to be her undoing. Claudine Gay has resigned from the presidency gay Harvard. Harvard President Claudine Gay is under fire not just for her answers before Congress, but allegations of plagiarism.

The substance of the charge does not matter in these circumstances—only its usefulness to the political cause. We saw this same defensive pattern emerge in the early s controversy around Michael Bellesiles, then a history professor at Emory University.

Harvard University has shed fresh light on the ongoing investigation into plagiarism accusations against former president Claudine Gay, including that an independent body recommended a broader review after substantiating some of the complaints.

FILE - Harvard President Claudine Gay speaks during a hearing of the House Committee on Education on Capitol Hill, Dec. 5, in Washington. As the month-long plagiarism saga played out, it became increasingly apparent to any outside observer that Claudine Gay no longer possessed the moral authority to lead the university under its own policies, let alone longstanding norms of scholarly ethics.

Longstanding academic conventions treat plagiarism as a cardinal sin of scholarship, and Harvard is no exception. By Phillip W. January 15, News Article.

Understanding the Claudine Gay

Much like Claudine Gay, Kruse cribbed text from other authors without the requisite quotation marks or, in some cases, citations. Here’s what’s going on. When academia refuses to police its own for blatantly political reasons, as happened with Claudine Gay, it takes outside voices to take up that task.

Students at Harvard face severe consequences for similar behavior, including year-long suspensions from classes or even expulsion from the university. In disregarding the evidence, they push the boundaries of academic ethics into self-contradictory absurdities.

Harvard President Claudine Gay resigned Tuesday amid plagiarism allegations.